| Men’s Soccer | |
| Sean Bolger (‘05) | Longwood University |
| Matt Debnam (‘05) | Lees-McRae |
| Justin Head (‘05) | UNC Ashville |
| Josh Buck (‘06) | St. Andrews |
| Judd Lawrence (‘06) | UNC Asheville |
| Justin Hatfield (‘06) | Oakland University |
| Greg Walters (‘06) | Appalachian State U. |
| Sean Nguyen (‘07) | University of South Carolina |
| Andre Petrov (‘07) | Belmont Abbey |
| Angelo Acquah (‘08) | Mount Olive |
| Alexis Aquirre (‘08) | Belmont Abbey |
| Ricky Gasca (‘08) | Houston Baptist University |
| Shane Daly (‘09) | Johnson & Whales U. |
| Roberto Perez (‘09) | Pfeiffer University |
| Justin Tyson (‘09) | Urbana University |
| Eddie West (‘09) | Chaminade University |
| Brian Kirkman (‘10) | Greensboro College |
| Marcus Krueger (‘10) | Mount Olive College |
| Vieux Sarr (‘10) | Mount Olive College |
| Earl Floyd (‘11) | Greensboro College |
| Sven Kulovic (‘11) | Limestone College |
| Manbi Nyepon (‘11) | Greensboro College |
| Jonah Powers-Myszka (‘11) | Campbell University |
| Adam Smith ('11) | Greensboro College |
| Marc Wleh (‘11) | Greensboro College |
| Matt Moore ('11) | North Carolina Wesleyan |
| Gentry Johnson (‘12) | Greensboro College |
| Bryant Rico ('12) | Northwood University-Florida |
| Spencer Tayloe (‘12) | UNCW |
| Robert Sandidge ('13) | Guilford College |
| Abdul Faal ('13) | Guilford College |
| Zachary Melvin ('14) | Belmont Abbey |
| Nate Pace ('15) | Univ. of Mount Olive |
| Andrew Goodman ('16) | Appalachian State University |
| Tyus Lopez ('16) | Catawba College |
| Alex Degrassi ('18) | Virginia Wesleyan University |
| Alfredo Martinez ('18) | William Peace University |
| Christian Vega ('19) | University of Mount Olive |
| Charles Basse ('19) | Queens University of Charlotte |
| Charles Barkman ('20) | Bob Jones University |
| Chase Lucas ('20) | Wayland Baptist University |
| Cisco Tavara ('20) | William Penn University |
| Tyler Kesser ('20) | Shaw University |
| Quavon White ('21) | Florida Memorial University |
| Tristan Torbett ('21) | Gallaudet University |
| Ethan James ('22) | Spalding University |
| Caleb Woodard ('23) | Queens College |
| Logan Wipperfurth ('23) | Hampton-Sydney College |
| Alejandro Sepulveda ('24) | Barton College |
| Barrett Klapprodt ('24) | Lynn University |
| Tyler Kroma ('24) | Belmont Abbey College |
| Emilio Roman ('24) | USC Aiken |